4/19/2021 0:00:01
The truth is that the intellectual production carried out by the Arab thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie is something that deserves praise and appreciation because he was able to open new windows for the Arab reader to peer through his mind to read and understand the history that created the surrounding reality around us… regardless of whether we agree or disagree with his intellectual production. .
At least, it is a summary of research and readings that any researcher can rely on as a basis for constructing any new reading, and it is a very healthy state in a cultural reality that has stopped opening new, unthought-of windows and is content with only regurgitating the old thinker.
I respect his production as an ordinary reader, and the truth is that I may consider myself an exploitative type when I stop playing the role of an ordinary reader and move to the role of an ordinary researcher, and make something like Al-Rubaie’s production a ready-made basis for me to rely on and save me from tiring intelligent, academic, and scientific research in books and books. Languages, ancient archives, and manuscripts provide me with a summary through which I can think, given the difficulty of having such research and intellectual capabilities available to me.
I also thank the thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie for sponsoring many cultural seminars to discuss his intellectual production, in addition to raising intellectual and scientific issues related to today’s reality around us in our Arab world.
but
The truth is that there is a negative side in all of the above, not on the part of the thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie… but on the part of the recipient… and I hope that my words are not understood from any side except only one side, which is the public contribution to the truth.
What’s the downside?!
It is the fear that theories with all their errors will become entrenched, and have not been subjected to sufficient criticism, and will later become an established collective consciousness that is difficult to remove… especially since our societies love everything new, not because it is true, but only because it is new, and then it becomes… The process is unscientific.
In other words… these theories must be presented for continuous scientific criticism and many books must be published, so that these theories are subjected to sifting, and the correct value is in criticism and not in propaganda. Perhaps through this situation other, more correct theories will emerge that will be a new, healthy, different awareness. about others .
What is important is constant, continuous criticism, and I believe that any researcher or thinker will be very happy with any scientific criticism that is presented about his intellectual production. Rather, he will give it its due right, and perhaps the real researcher will find in some of them correct aspects that he did not take into account in his production, and it may contribute to his producing a new production that he will consider a stage. Another idea is called reviews.
I think that it is natural for any researcher or thinker that his intellectual journey must go through a stage of reviews.
The truth is that I am not at all at the intellectual and scientific level of the Arab thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie, but I consider myself a very ordinary reader, with an average level of education. I agree in the general framework of some of what Al-Rubaie raises on many issues, but I radically disagree with him on all the theories that he presents…. and I will try to discuss some of these issues not in the capacity of a researcher or reader, but rather as a very ordinary person.
Among these theories is that Christianity originated in Yemen.
—————————-
Let me discuss this theory with Fadel Al-Rubaie on the basis that I am an ordinary person and an ordinary reader:
■ When Al-Rubaie says that Christianity originated in Yemen, the natural question is: What is meant by the word Yemen?!
Is the image that Al-Rubaie means by the word “Yemen” the basic borders of Yemen today?! ..Does he consider Asir and Najran to be Yemeni or does he not consider them Yemeni, because I heard him in an interview in which he said: The geography of the Jewish book is not in Asir but in Yemen.
Does the thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie not consider Asir part of the geography of Yemen?
So… he thinks in the logic of the modern Sykes-Picot borders, and this is considered a scientific error because it confines the researcher to iron concepts and intellectual limits that prevent him from a realistic, objective reading of the land and history.
If they are the same as the current limits that Fadel Al-Rubaie means, then the logical questions are:
Why does the mind that thinks respond to Sykes-Picot’s limitations?
– Why does this mind that thinks about explaining ancient phenomena interact with the thinking images produced by modern intellectual concepts such as the Sykes-Picot limits?!
– Why is the mind subject to an external authority that gives it an awareness that looks at the phenomena around us within a limited, modern framework?!
Why does the mind that thinks in our present time see the old world from a perspective and a new world different from the old world?
– Why do even ancient abstract ideas and beliefs respond to a modern geopolitical framework?!
■ Now…. Let me ask a question as a normal person?! What does it mean…that a belief originates in a geographical area, or in other words, how can we attribute a belief to a specific geography?!
– For example…. I am in Yemen and I firmly believe that there are living creatures that have not yet been discovered on earth. Is this my belief that we can say about the origin of Yemen?!
– Are ideas related to a place?!
– How can we imagine the idea that a belief has its origins in a specific land? Does this mean that the rest of the other lands never reached such a belief?!
– Then how can I determine the geographical origin of abstract ideas that exist only in the mind and heart?!
– If we say that the origin of the kangaroo (a material thing) is Australia, then it is true and without doubt, and if we say that the origin of the coffee tree (a material thing) is Yemen, it may be logical, but how can I determine the origin of a belief that exists in the mind and heart and attribute it to it? For a specific geography?!
– Did Marxism originate in Germany, Russia, or England, or was it a state of general awareness that emerged in Europe, and was there a force that spread these ideas?! ……. And this in a modern era has become well observable.. So how can a belief in an ancient world be observed and understood and the place in which it appeared?!
■ What is the meaning of Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
– Does Christianity mean that there were people in the past who always carried a cross with them and performed a prayer with three kisses, and believed that the world was created through three hypostases?!
So how can we see people’s beliefs in the past and see their prayers and symbols in their chests?!
■ So what is the meaning of Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
– Does he mean…that there were people in the past who decided one day and suddenly agreed to create a religion and believed that there was a horizontal world that united with a vertical world and at the meeting point the world and life were formed, and after that an absolute entity descended? And he became human and life was formed?
– Or does he mean…that there were people in the past who concluded that life was a heavenly and earthly union, and thus a creature of two natures was born?
– Or does he mean…. that there were people in the past who worshiped three ancient gods, according to what the West has learned for us in all the religions of ancient civilizations in the region, and people’s worship developed according to Darwin’s theory at a period of time that reached the Christian model when the divine was incarnated in the earth ?
If the belief is this….. then I believe that this is symbolic, geometric, abstract, imaginative thinking, which had no reality in the ancient world, and the ancient world did not experience such awareness.
Why ?!
Man is the only being who can imagine and perform abstract thinking processes, and the world around us is made up of two things: reality and mind.
The mind has two things… logic and imagination
Logic unites with reality, while imagination separates from reality.
In mathematics… the human imaginative mind can correctly solve mathematical and engineering equations… because mathematics and engineering are a realistic, logical world that can be found and projected into reality, meaning that the mind has obtained its logic from reality.
You impose a horizontal line that intersects a vertical line, and at that meeting point you draw a line inclined to the right, and at the end of the point of the line you draw a vertical line and calculate the angles and lengths and so on……. You can project such models into reality… They are things of reality that exist…Logic.
But when you turn the symbols of mathematics and engineering into symbols for mental things, and you try to apply the laws of engineering and mathematics to them, and you think that you will get results like the results of engineering… it is a mistake.
Or in other words… when you believe that what applies in mathematics applies to mental terms in life… and that life, for example, is the intersection of the heavenly with the earthly, and the angle is the extent of the view of the world, this does not express facts or Beliefs, but rather imaginary mental images created by the imaginative mind, have no reality on the ground of reality, that is, they can never be projected into reality…..that is, they cannot occur in reality.
Man in ancient times… did not think in this mathematical, geometric way of interpreting the world. This is awareness and a way of thinking created by the world of Greek symbols, which tries to create astonishment in people’s minds by transforming geometric symbols into mental symbols that cannot be embodied in reality, so the imaginative mind interacts with them. According to the laws of geometry, the astonishment of the geometric-mathematical solution occurs, and the person then believes in its reality, that it is logic, and that it is reality….. without knowing that he is solving mathematical and geometric laws in his mind after they have disappeared inside mental moral symbols.
What is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
Or does he not mean all of the above… Rather, he means that Christianity is a religion that appeared as a result of the appearance of only one person named Christ, and because of him Christianity was formed according to an ancient form before arriving at the modern form.
– If this is the case… then one person cannot create anything new and will not present anything new in a society that has an old belief, and he cannot establish a religion and there is no need for a new religion in a society that has an old belief.
– Or does he mean…that this man was the one who saved the Al-Yahoud from captivity and wanted to return them to their land and the Holy Promised Land?
But the question is whether this is a real world or an imaginary world, and the matter must be separated… because the mind possesses two things: logic and imagination.
■ What is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
Or does he mean… by Christianity the current form that exists in the world?!
If he meant the current form, then the logical question for thinker Fadel Al-Rubaie is:
If Christianity originated in Yemen, then why did it disappear from there and there is no trace of it in Yemen, and then it spread to Europe among the white man?!
Reason and realistic logic say… that it is assumed that the country of origin must have this religion deep and this belief more firmly established than in any other place……. Rather, it must be an unforgettable place as a first station for the religion and you will find There is depth to this religion in its surroundings, and it has clear effects on earth.
But there is no trace of it in Yemen?!
Although Islam came after Christianity and Judaism according to Roman times, and Christianity came after Judaism, we never saw any Christian manifestations in Yemen, and Al-Yahoud remained as many as the number of fingers in Yemen until the modern era, and there is also no ancient trace of them in Yemen. How is it possible that Christianity originated in Yemen?!
■ So what is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
Does he mean by Christianity the current image of people who believe that Allah had a son and was crucified?!
If by Christianity Al-Rubaie means a philosophy similar to the philosophy of symbols, the union of the divine with the earthly, the emergence of the child, and the formation of the world, then these are merely mental symbols in Al-Rubaie’s mind that came from modern Greek printed books and are not a doctrine, which tried to make man believe that man in ancient times used to think like this. The unseen world is understood in a geometric-mathematical way… by placing religious names within a geometric design. When thinking about them, the mind enters into more abstraction and arrives at mathematical solutions that create amazement in a person’s mind, just as logical geometry creates amazement in the mind. When a person arrives at the solution through abstract thinking and imagination…then the person comes to believe that it is a logical reality that exists on earth just like the reality of mathematical geometry. The West wrote those symbols and made them gods and attributed them to ancient civilizations. So people recently believed that the ancient person used to think. That way.
■ What is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
Does Christianity mean that it means believing in the book of the Al-Yahoud, which is similar to the book of Muslims, but in different languages?!
So let’s focus on this point
If the thinker meant when he said that Christianity originated in Yemen, and by it he meant a religion that carries the Book of the Old and New Testaments… then the logical question is: Why does the Christian today not carry with him the Holy Qur’an, as it is a book similar to the book of the Al-Yahoud?!
Don’t tell me that Islam came after Christianity… because if we build on this logic then we will ask a logical question:
How can I determine the age of religions? Is there a scientific device such as a carbon analysis device through which I can determine the age of religions and beliefs on Earth?!
If it is through the books and history that have reached us, then all that has reached us is the books of a modern printer that has the same age… and thinking from within this modern printed world makes the mind not understand the past… because it is logical to believe that the ancient world cannot He understood it through texts written recently, but also through ancient texts.
Does he mean by Christianity…the current form that believes in a book from (Yahweh), and deals with the same stories of the prophets that the Holy Qur’an deals with, the book of the majority of the population of Yemen who follow the religion of Islam, but in a different language and in a different style?
So why don’t Al-Nasarah carry the Qur’an with them instead of the Jewish book?!
So why does Christianity currently have the Jewish book with it?!
Do not tell me…that it is a book from Allah and it is the Torah, because the Torah found in the Muslim Qur’an was spoken by a Allah whose name is (Allah), while the Al-Yahoud have a book from a Allah whose name is (Yahweh) and it is not from (Yahweh). Allah) but from (Yahweh)
So why do they not believe in the Qur’an? Is it because the Qur’an says about them:
{And among them is a party who distort the Book with their tongues so that you may think it is from the Book, but it is not from the Book, and they say, “It is from Allah,” but it is not from Allah, and they say lies about Allah while they know.}
■ So what is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
Does Al-Rubaie mean… that there was a person who appeared in Yemen… and people were waiting for him to become a faith that people would believe in, or does Al-Rubaie mean that Christ came to liberate the Al-Yahoud of Yemen in Babylon and a religion was formed among the Al-Yahoud and they made it the basis of their religion… and this is Religion did not spread in Yemen or in the region…. Rather, it spread in France, Britain, and all of Europe at the hands of Greek messengers, then the white man spread it in America, Africa, and Asia as he went out to occupy the land.
■ So what is the Christianity that Fadel Al-Rubaie means?!
If Al-Rubaie means by Christianity it is a religion without the Old and New Testaments…. Then the logical question is: On what basis was it called Christianity so that we believe that it originated in Yemen?!
The people of Yemen currently have a Qur’an that talks about a Muslim messenger from Allah named Issa who believes in Allah…while Christianity currently believes in a person with two names Jesus and Yasouaa (Joshua). He was Jewish, and believes in a Allah whose name is Jehovah and the Allah.
———————–
Why did Fadel Al-Rubaie come up with the theory that Christianity originated in Yemen?
First, let us list the foundations that shaped the thinking mind of Fadel Al-Rubaie and who produced all his theories, which are:
– His outlook borders on Sykes-Picot.
– The book of reality is neglected by him
– His belief in the Darwinian Allah
– His belief in Roman times
The Book of the Al-Yahoud is considered a standard reference
– It is based on unreliable primary texts
If you think about the essence of his theory, which says that Christianity originated in Yemen, you will find that it is based on three of the previous foundations:
1- The first basis: the Sykes-Picot border view.
This is the most clear basis for this theory and the rest of his other theories. He believes, for example, that religions, languages, and beliefs only respond to modern political borders, and that he cannot read religion and language from an open space, and from a general, comprehensive view of the entire earth. Rather, his mind is always confined to modern political borders in an attempt to understand the phenomenon.
If the mind is subject to the authority of a modern concept, and it draws a closed frame of thought within the scope of modern geographical borders… and wants to think about interpreting the phenomena of the ancient world, then the thinking of this mind will never depart from the authority of the modern concept and will not reach the vision of the ancient world and its interpretation. The phenomena in it will never be subject to a modern cognitive authority. Rather, this mind will contribute to giving that modern cognitive authority additional power in shaping people’s current awareness in a way that is contrary to the awareness of ancient reality.
When the mind emerges from the authority of the frameworks of intellectual concepts created by a modern authority, then it can think about the issue in a more liberal and more objective way, and the mind’s vision of the phenomena will be greater, clearer, and closer to the truth, and then Fadel Al-Rubaie’s theory will be like: Christianity originated, for example. In the south of the island…. Instead of his first theory, Christianity originated in Yemen.
Then the audience will ask: Are Oman, Somalia, and Abyssinia within the geographical scope of the first emergence of Christianity?!
The truth is that the ancient world did not know the awareness of geographical borders when it interacted with existential phenomena, and its awareness never responded to modern basic borders when it interacted with the phenomena around it, and then such an idea would be further from the truth and would not come close to the correct picture.
In ancient times, while creating any phenomenon around him, man looked at the world from within a completely open environment, meaning that he was connected with all of nature and not confined within a specific geographical space.
2- The second basis: The book of reality is neglected by him
Fadel Al-Rubaie enters into the laws of the magical worlds in interpreting reality, because of his belief in the texts of printer’s books as axioms, and his neglect of the book of reality.
(Adnan) in the cartoon series (Adnan and Lynel) jumped from the top of the very high castle and reached the ground on his feet. He did not actually die in the series and continued in the starring role until the end of the series. However, in the reality book, if a person jumped from that same height… He will die immediately, and his body will be torn apart.
It is also possible to create a scenario in a cartoon series in which a king comes from Iraq to Yemen and captivates a large tribe because they were intercepting trade convoys, and takes them from Yemen to Iraq and travels with them all that great distance, and they live in Babylon, then after a century they are liberated. And they return to Yemen, and there they wrote the Torah, but in the book of reality, if there is a tribe that obstructs the path of the caravans, a person will go to war and fight them only, and he does not need to take them to his country, and no one will be able to take them captive. Will he put them in prisons inside Babylon, and their book cannot be written? In Babylon, all of Yemen is devoid of the Torah, so they do not need a captivity journey for the Torah to be written in Babylon.
The truth is that our researchers, including Fadel Al-Rubaie, search all books, but they forget the book of reality. They do not consider it a book containing scientific information…….. Rather, they consider printer’s books scientific material, and they believe everything in printer’s books not because they are True, but because they are written in books, one of the signs of an intellectual among us has become the number of printer’s books he has read.
This is the essence of the disagreement between us and them, and the reasons for our continuous criticism of their theories that contradict a deep and well-established reality on earth.
For example… Fadel Al-Rubaie believes that Christianity originated in Yemen, because he believes that the geography of the Jewish book is in Yemen, and Christ was Jewish, and therefore Christ must have left Yemen in order to liberate them and return them to the Holy Land.
But the realistic question that Fadel Al-Rubaie never asked: Is Judaism a natural religion that emerged naturally, and passed through a natural historical context on earth, so that he could build his theory on a previous theory that he was not sure of?
No… its reality says very clearly that it is a religious engineering project on earth designed by a power that is above only, and that power that created Judaism tried to give it an ancient, cartoonish historical context on earth only.
For example… the printer’s books say that it is a 3,000-year-old religion, but the reality says that it is a modern religion due to the small number that embrace it, even if it is a non-proselytizing religion. Being 3,000 years old would make its population very large. If the population of my city was 70 years ago It is 30 thousand, and today their number reaches 200 thousand, so what if the age was 3000 years?
This is not a natural and realistic historical context for a natural religion on Earth
And for example… Printer books say that it is a religion and they have a religious book written in Hebrew for 3000 years, which is their original language, but 100 years ago there was no Jew in the whole earth who could speak Hebrew. Rather, they spoke languages. Other societies lived among them, and the language was limited to clerics who were responsible for explaining their book.
If Hebrew had actually been a living language 3,000 years ago, we would have seen Jewish communities and villages all over the world that spoke to each other only in Hebrew, like the residents of the region, but this reality did not appear everywhere on earth.
This is not a realistic historical context for a natural language on Earth.
The Al-Yahoud had the Himyarite Kingdom in Yemen 2000 years ago after a king appeared who adopted Judaism named Dhu Nuwas….. But the reality of the Al-Yahoud in Yemen was unnatural. They were somewhat outcast, and if they belonged to the tribes of Yemen, their reality would not have been that, because Tribal affiliation will put them in an equal position within the tribe, and perhaps tribal affiliation will break the barrier of religion, because tribal affiliation is strong, but their presence was in outer neighborhoods in the cities, and they did not practice agriculture, so that we believe that they inherited land.
This is not a realistic historical context of a natural society that lived on Earth
Judaism…..as a religion, a language, a book, and an existence on earth…..is a reality that is not natural at all. Rather, it is very clear that it is a religious engineering project designed by a powerful force on earth, and it carried out this engineering as a strategic project.
This fact is only realized by those who read the book of reality.
Because of the great neglect of the book “Al-Waqi’” in study and research, other theories are always coming out by many researchers, such as the theories of Fadel Al-Rubaie, among which is a theory that says that what is called Christianity (Christianity) originated in Yemen. The idea is that Christ was the savior of the Al-Yahoud from captivity, and returned them to Yemen to the Promised Land.
It is as if Fadel Al-Rubaie never reads reality, as it is impossible for a tribal idea about a person who wanted to rid his tribe of captivity and return them to their holy land in Yemen, to become a global religion and belief.
Rather, it is realistically supposed that it is a religion that will be limited to Yemen only, that is, a tribal religion, but in the reality of Yemen there is no manifestation of a tribal religion that is different from the world, nor are there any manifestations of an ancient Christian presence in it, even if the printer wrote and told him about the Al-Nasarah of Najran.
Also, Fadel Al-Rubaie does not see in reality……… that the so-called Christianity, which is believed to have the origin of a tribal idea only, was not spread by the Yemenis in all parts of the earth, but rather, no creature from the region spread it on the earth, but rather the man did White in Europe spread it to all countries of the world, from America to Africa and Asia.
3- The third basis: The book of the Al-Yahoud is considered a standard reference
The truth is that Fadel Al-Rubaie did not do anything new, except to establish and consolidate in the Muslim mind the idea that the reference for ruling on historical issues is the Book of the Bible, which the West believes in. The fundamental difference in his theories from the rest of the other theories is in the processes of correct interpretation and correct translation of the Book of the Bible. Just what he says.
For this reason………many theories about our history are revealed at every period and rely on the Book of the Bible as a reference for reading history, religion, etc.
For example……….a theory came out saying that the Prophet Ibrahim was a Hebrew born in Iraq, then after a period of time a theory came out that said the geography of the Jewish book was in Asir, and after a while a theory came out saying that the geography of the Jewish book was in Yemen, and then after a period of time it came out A theory says that the Babylonian captivity occurred in Yemen and not in Palestine. Then, after a period of time, a theory emerges that says that Jerusalem is in Yemen. Then, after a period of time, a theory emerges that says that the Prophet Ibrahim lived in Yemen, and then after a period of time, a theory emerges that says that Christianity emerged from Yemen.
Each of the previous theories began to attract an audience, and readers began to adopt such theories and become fanatical about them.
It is really a problem… There is no certainty in reading ancient history, because we rely on the Book of the Bible as a reference in interpreting our history.
These theories that rely on the Book of the Bible and attract masses have made our societies suffer from a fractured memory, and our societies do not know that they have been penetrated by another book and they have made them believe that it was from Allah to explain their history and religion… and this is the real reason for this scene we have. …..Relying on printer’s books and Bible books.
The truth is….. We did not write our history ourselves, and there are those who wrote a new history for us after our old written records were hidden, and all our historians do is copy and paste the history that was written for us in the printer’s books or repeat the history that was written. It came to us in the books of the printer, or relying on the Bible book, and believing that it is a book that deals with a real history that took place on earth.
This is the truth…… Our societies have a fractured memory, and this is the reason why people gather around historical theories, in an attempt to fill the gap in their memory, which was caused by the process of concealing those ancient written records of people.
This is evidenced by the fact that when we look at these theories…we will find that all of these theories do not represent the Muslim community at all, and do not represent its memory. Theories about the book of the Al-Yahoud, Jerusalem, and the Babylonian captivity do not represent the memory of any person in the region, because the Muslim does not He believes in something called Jerusalem and the Book of the Al-Yahoud, but our historians fall into a scientific error, believing that the Book of the Al-Yahoud represents a historical memory for the people on earth. The Muslim has different names from the names of the Book of the Al-Yahoud.
The Muslim community believes in Al-Masjid Al Haram and does not believe in the Temple…. Therefore, the Temple does not represent a real historical memory for it until historian Fadel Al-Rubaie is interested in talking about it to us.
The Muslim community believes in the Torah and does not believe in the Book of the Al-Yahoud, and therefore the Book of the Al-Yahoud does not represent a real historical memory for it until historian Fadel Al-Rubaie is interested in talking about it to us.
The Muslim community did not experience the Babylonian captivity and does not believe in it. Therefore, the Babylonian captivity does not represent a real historical memory for it so that our historians care to talk about it.
The Muslim community only believes in Bakkah and does not believe in Jerusalem, and therefore Jerusalem does not represent a real historical memory for it until the historian Fadel Al-Rubaie is interested in talking about it to us.
The Muslim community believes in his father Ibrahim and does not believe in the Hebrew or Kurdish Ibrahim, and therefore Ibrahim in the book of the Al-Yahoud does not represent a real historical memory for him until the historian Fadel Al-Rubaie is interested in talking about him to us.
Etc…..
Instead of the historian Fadel Al-Rubaie writing for the Muslim community in Yemen and in the region the true history of Bakkah and Al-Masjid Al Haram in which he believes, he began writing his own historical theories about Jerusalem, the Temple, and the captivity. Instead of Fadel Al-Rubaie writing a history for the Muslim community in Yemen and in the region Regarding the Torah, which he believes in and which Allah revealed as light and guidance, he began writing historical theories to him that the book of the Al-Yahoud is the Torah, which is an ancient Yemeni book. Instead of Fadel Al-Rubaie writing to the Muslim community in Yemen the true history of Islam is its religion, they began writing historical theories to it that it is its religion. Christianity originates in Yemen.
———–
How true is this theory?
If we go to the foundations that Fadel Al-Rubaie relied on in presenting this theory, we will find that he neglected three things.
For example
Sykes-Picot’s vision made him neglect the entire earth as a continuous space
Relying on printer’s books made him neglect reality
Adopting the Book of the Bible as a reference for measurement made him neglect the Holy Qur’an
He neglected three things: the one earth, reality, and the Qur’an, and this makes his reading a vaguely subjective reading.
Because objectivity imposes on him not to neglect the entire earth as an earth while developing his theory. Objectivity also imposes on him not to neglect the book of reality as long as he relies on the printer’s books in developing his theories. Objectivity also imposes that he does not neglect the Qur’an as long as he relies on the Bible book in developing his theories.
Now…..we can dissect his theory through those three things he neglected.
Reading the history of religion from a comprehensive view of the whole earth… will make us put forward an idea in understanding the subject of religion and beliefs and its history, and this idea says that there is something called human nature on earth. This nature is the one upon which the first man was found on all earth, and this The idea is an idea that is completely absent from Fadel Al-Rubaie and his fans when they read religion.
No one will be able to truly understand the history of religions on earth while the idea of the first nature is absent from him, because he will enter into magical worlds in explaining the origin of religions.
{So set your face upright to the religion. Allah created the manner in which He created the people. There is no altering Allah’s creation. That is the upright religion, but most people do not know. (30) They turn to it, and fear Him, and establish prayer, and do not be of the polytheists. (31) Of those who divided their religion and were sects, each party rejoicing in what they have.}
Also, reading the history of religion from the book Al-Waqi’ah… will make us believe that all these theories are nothing but a repetition of printed texts only, from the Bible and history books.
It makes us believe that Fadel Al-Rubaie and the masses who adopt these theories are not on anything at all… because there is another book that is very important and neglected by them and does not, in their view, have any cognitive or scientific value in historical issues, and they do not consider it a reference. Measurement and arbitration….and this book is the Holy Qur’an, the revelation of the first nature on earth.
If Fadel Al-Rubaie took five minutes to read and ponder the Qur’an, he would know the whole story very easily, and he would realize that Allah describes him (thus those who do not know say the same as they say), and that he only repeats the texts of others that they said with their mouths only in the printer’s books and in the Bible book. .
Because he does not know that the speech is telling him about a book that is read in a clear Arabic language, in which is written a story about Issa and his mother Maryam, written in a clear Arabic language.
He will know exactly that the speech is not talking to him about a person named Jesus or Yasouaa, but rather it is talking to him about a person named Issa in a holy book whose words do not change, and Issa is just a word in the book of Allah over which two Western powers disagreed while they were reciting the book.
He will know that this story about a person who was crucified and killed during the era of the Roman Empire is a fake story, just a literary novel in printer’s books only, and that they likened to him the character of Issa, written in an ancient sacred book written in the lines of the Torah, with a character named Jesus (Yasouaa / Joshua) in the printer’s books who was killed. And crucified.
And he will know that the story of Christ, the Son of Allah, is merely an invention by a corrupting force that wanted to create a global religion… after it disbelieved in the truth recorded in the book and said against Allah… only lies.
{And when Allah took a covenant from those who were given the Book that you will make it clear to the people and do not conceal it, so they threw it behind their backs and bought it for a small price, so evil is what they bought.}
{And Al-Yahoud said is not Al-Nasarah on anything, and Al-Nasarah said The Al-Yahoud are not upon anything, and they recite the Book. Thus those who do not know say the same as their saying. Allah will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection in what they differed about.}
{And Al-Yahoud said Uzair, son of Allah, and Al-Nasarah said Christ, son of Allah. That is what they say with their mouths, they imitate the words of those who disbelieved before. Allah has killed them. How can they be deceived? (30) They have taken their rabbis and monks as Allah[s] other than Allah and the Massih, son of Maryam, and they were commanded only to worship one Allah. There is no Allah but Him. Glory be to Him above what they associate with Him. (31)}
{Then because they broke their covenant and disbelieved in the verses of Allah and killed the prophets unjustly and said, “Our hearts are uncircumcised.” Rather, Allah has sealed them with their disbelief, so they believe only a little. (155) And because of their disbelief and their saying against Maryam is a great slander (156) and their saying, “Indeed, we killed the Massih, Issa, son of Maryam, the Messenger of Allah.” And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, but in an imitation. Indeed, those who disagreed about it were in doubt about it. They had no knowledge of it except following conjecture, and they did not kill him for certain.
{O People of the Book, do not go to extremes in your religion, and do not say about Allah anything but the truth. Indeed, the Massih, Issa, son of Maryam, is the Messenger of Allah, and His word which He delivered to Maryam, and a spirit from Him, so believe in Allah and His messengers, and do not say three things: “Desist is better for you.” Allah is but one Allah. Glory be to Him to have a son. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is in the heavens. on earth, and Allah is sufficient as a disposer of affairs.}
And Fadel Al-Rubaie, who does not know what the book is, will know that what is called Judaism and Christianity is a project created by two powers in the West out of hatred among themselves, to spread it on earth… after they were able to hide the Muslim book from the Muslims, after they falsified and distorted its reading. And they made it a foreign language.
{Do you hope that they will believe in you, when a group of them used to hear the words of Allah and then distort them after they had understood them while they knew? (75) And when they met those who believed, they said, “We believe,” and when they were alone with one another, they said, “Will you inform them of what Allah has revealed to you, so that they may dispute with you concerning it before your Allah? Will you not understand?” (76) First. They know that Allah knows what they conceal and what they declare. (77) And among them are unlettered people who do not know the Book except in wishful thinking, and they only surmise. (78) So woe to those who write the Book with their own hands and then say, “This is from Allah,” in order to exchange it for a small price. So woe to them for what their hands have written, and woe to them for what they earn.
{The religion with Allah is Islam, and those who were given the Book did not differ except after knowledge had come to them out of envy among themselves. And whoever disbelieves in the verses of Allah, then Allah is quick to judge. (19) And if they dispute with you, say, “I have submitted my face to Allah, and whoever follows them.” And say to those who were given the Book and to the unlettered people, “Have you submitted?” If they submit, then they are guided, even if they turn away. It is your responsibility only to convey the message; Allah is All-Seer of His servants (20)}
And since I live in Yemen… and I read the reality well and we have a living popular memory that is healthier and better than the artificial memory found in the printer’s books that reached the whole world, I say to him: Judaism is a Western project to settle a religion in our region, and it has been accomplished. The matter was in the dark gap period before the entry of the printer, in order to gather them after a while and create a special state for them that would manage the ambitions of the Western powers. Therefore, what is called Christianity is also a project of a Western religion that spread, not because of its antiquity, but because of the European man.
All of Africa, all of America, and some of Asia…all of them embraced Christianity at the hands of the white man only, and its history in those countries is recent.
If in Yemen there is no presence in our popular memory of Al-Yahoud 150 years ago… The Al-Yahoud are very close in age and their numbers disgrace them… They were in small gatherings of five. Individuals wherever they are, and any talk other than this is a lie…. It is all false awareness interacting with the printer’s books.
Also, there is a very natural, scientific, and realistic law…but perhaps the thinker Al-Rabi’ never adopts it in the rules of research and thinking, because it is a municipal law, and perhaps he uses Western approaches, and perhaps if he adopted this law and understood it well and dealt with With him as a tool for scientific research, perhaps he would understand the game well.
The law that we inherited from our ancestors says: An authentic person’s documents are always original and true.
I do not mean the printer’s books, they are books written by unknown people to make Muslims of few origins in their homelands.. I mean the Qur’an, the highest sacred text for Muslims……and the Al-Yahoud who carry a book similar to the Qur’an in terms of topics and in a strange language that no one speaks, nor No one knows their origin, and according to this realistic and scientific natural law, the Qur’an preceded the writings of the Al-Yahoud in time.
The survival and continuation of Christianity and Judaism depend on the continued Muslim belief that Allah created previous religions before Islam and gave them books such as the Qur’an.
That is, the rise of Christianity and Judaism in the world took place at the expense of the Muslim’s faith, at the expense of deceiving the Muslim, and at the expense of falsifying the Muslim mind with these texts and history, because the Muslim carries the oldest religion on earth, and it is the religion of Allah’s innate nature and the innate nature of the first human being. the earth .
This is the nature that they made believe that there are religions that Allah revealed before them, and that their books are from Allah, while they are only political projects, and their books were written by a political system, and they are religions with a political function to serve Europe and a security function to penetrate a region that carries information from the book in its original tongue. .
These religions associated with the West… are a deliberate act by the Western project in one period and not the product of the context of a realistic history that took place on earth according to what is found in the printer’s books.
finally:
The truth… is that all this intellectual chaos related to history, time and religion is around us… because today’s Muslims are misled and a global game created by the West has been played out on them… after they were able to hide the book from the Muslims. They created a Dirar Mosque for Muslims in Mecca, wrote a new fake historical and temporal memory for them inside the printer’s books, and made their religions precede Islam in their fake chronological calendar, to steal the Muslim’s time, steal his land, steal his awareness, steal his tongue, and steal his religious book.
{They want to extinguish the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah refuses except to perfect His light, even if the disbelievers hate it. It is He who sent His Messenger with guidance and the religion of truth to make it prevail over all religions, even if the polytheists hate it.}
{It is He who sent among the unlettered people a messenger from among themselves who recites to them His verses and purifies them and teaches them the Book and the wisdom, even though before they had been in clear error.}
{The people were one nation, so Allah sent the prophets as bearers of good tidings and warnings, and sent down with them the Book with the truth, that He might judge between the people in that in which they differed, and none differed in it except those who were given it, after the clear proofs had come to them, out of envy among themselves. So Allah guided those who believed to the truth to the truth, with His permission, Allah guides whom He wills to a straight path. }